Having kept up with all the lists, friends, foes, and those in between it’s probably time to build my own. As mentioned, last year’s favorite was Bitte Orca. Angeline put it on yesterday, saying she’d like to get into them more. It helped me to revisit the feelings I have about those sounds.
There is one record this year that will also transport me, although I don’t think it’s my favorite of the year, its a close second dare I say tied for first. LCD Soundsystem’s This Is Happening will always make me think of that last month of college. Wherever I am, who I’m with, it always reminds me of that place on Spencer Street and April and May in Ithaca. LCD was completely new to me, I hadn’t heard it previous which shocked people (mostly Aaron) and now I can’t imagine not knowing their sounds. Different from said previous record and, famously, maybe the last one they’ll do for a while…, the new sounds of This Is Happening remain unlike anything else this year. I like his crooked ways and what I know will be a famous crooked photo.

But down to the first, how can it not be Brothers? The Black Keys, ALSO new to me this year (sorry Aaron). I always had them around and knew 10 AM Automatic, but I never knew them like this. Brothers is rock and roll at it’s best. Fast, slow, loud, romantic, sexual and smart. I’ve heard countless interviews with both of them on radio since the album came out in May. On the World Cafe with David Dye, Auerbach and Carney explained how they felt different with this record. It was from their hip hop collaboration, Blackroc, that really taught them to revisit their instruments and keep it simple and soulful. Because of Brothers I listened to all their previous albums falling in love: Rubber Factory and their amazing debut The Big Come Up (with my favorite Beatles cover, She Said She Said.)
Now something I’ve just realized, both of these bands were new to me this year. If only ya’ll knew me in high school you would know what a big deal this is. In the past I used to be so closed off and far far away from new music, hiding it from myself as useless and messy, made without care and just for show. ‘These new bands don’t really know what music is,’ 16 year old me would say, ‘This isn’t really rock and roll.’ Thank god that’s over.
Just found this, Pitchfork’s list of upcoming releases. It’s like being handed a syllabus on the first day of classes, an overwhelming load. Only this time I’m looking forward to the homework. This is definitely the first full year I’ve had with new music, following it, being genuinely interested and closely following along. First year I’ve read Pitchfork regularly. I even took their reader’s poll.
Angeline asked me about liking certain things and whether or not I form my opinion before or after all of the press that I read. She asked why I read it. Well, I love the press. I like to read all the lists and reviews because I want to see what different publications have to say about the same records. Rolling Stone will write something differently about My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy than what the New York Times will say. Pitchfork’s review was much different than what SPIN had to say. The comparative list goes on. But for me in reading the press (the same way I followed Jonathan Franzen’s press, went to hear him speak, and tonight I finally bought FREEDOM and I’m 40 pages in…) the lists have all become redundant. Stereogum is the only list that included Tame Impala, a December release that got lost in the already completed best of the year reviews because they came out so late. But they have a loss with me because they did not include Brothers in their list. It came out in May, hardly late or early enough to overlook. I’m not sure what peoples‘ problems are.
I want to make a list, without rankings just so we’re clear, of my favorite records. Now if only there was a way I could directly get them to you.
Beach Fossils, Beach Fossils (tied for first with favorite live show with EELS. The 12 hours surrounding the time I saw this band were some of the strangest 12 that May day. I always remember it so vividly. Having not heard the band before, I fell in love with them. And I continue to do so every time I revisit this record. New release expected this month!)

lennon-a-like, trippy guitar, ever changing, never bored

the 1980s called, they like your band
Ariel Pink’s Haunted Graffiti, Before Today (Aaron, I should have listened to you sooner.) Deerhunter, Halcyon Digest. EELS, End Times (Saw them live at the 930 club in dc. This show was a game changer. Forever I love bearded men. I love EELS unlike a love for any other band. They rock loud and tight and remain calm while singing me to sleep.) Sleigh Bells, Treats (A band I overlooked for the first few months I knew them, maybe longer, just like Deerhunter. Recently I fell in love with them. A grittier Go! Team and thrashing sound, how can you not love this record?) Tame Impala, Innerspeaker (Thanks Sokol. Best find/mention you’ve had since I can’t remember when.) Annnnnd how can we forget, Yeasayer, Odd Blood (saw them perform live, for free at end of school year show. Did CTW during this, was sober with Aaron and we were two of few who kinda, mostly, hated their live performance.) Vampire Weekend Contra (A band I just within the last few days started listening to. Angeline’s frequent obsession always lead me to leave them out because I knew their hits from her and WICB. Contra is a great record full of forgettable sad lyrics and similes that are Ivy League.) Surfer Blood’s Astro Cast (I do love this. Saw them live at the 930 club, not great. They played in Ithaca many many moons ago and sadly I did not take Reece’s advice to go see them. Now they’re signed to Warner Brothers, I’m excited to see what sounds comes next.) How can I forget Kanye West’s My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy. I am only putting this record on this list because I’ve been in too long a relationship with it to leave it out. Including the story here would only get violently wordy.

polaroid, controversy, blank indie stares. what more do you want in an album cover?
Honorable mentions includes my personal discoveries this year. Weezer’s Pinkerton (also was re-released this year, I promise, no coincidence.) PAVEMENT (Malkmus..Lou Reed….it’s a match made in uneasy heaven. Also this year I rediscovered a comp. book of 90s alternative rock journalism/coverage. Including revisits to Smashing Pumpkins and above mentioned bands, I learned about Courtney Love and why I don’t understand the underbelly of Seattle Grunge.) The Go (Jack White plays lead guitar and sings back up on Whatcha Doin’. You will surly dance to this Detroit sound.) The biggest let down with largest questionable expectations, Best Coast. (In fact tonight at dinner the big mouthed, long winded girl at the table behind us was the in-the-flesh version of the Best Coast girl. Or what I imagine her to be like if she was yelling conversation to people who can’t get a word in. Obnoxious and animated, this girl did had her life together, where she rambled about graduate school programs and not the munchies. She also talked about her cats a lot.)
I just realized how long this has gotten. At first meant to be a list of my favorites, I’m sure I have left some out, it has turned into a parenthetical rant. Also note that these are MY favorites and not the best. Left out: Titus Andronicus, Janelle Monae, Erykah Badu, countless other great records. We must remember to differentiate our favorite from the best.
There has been a lot of talk lately about dessert island records. Records always seemed so definitive. Is it too easy to do desert island bands? Ones you simply cannot live without. Also there was a lot of talk about a band’s sound and how we can compare them to their own discography and those of their peers. (Example, rock and roll from the Who, Zeppelin and Floyd all had their own sounds. Meanwhile Small Black, Beach Fossils, Surfer Blood and Vampire Weekend are all in the same family of sounds, and sometimes you can’t tell them apart. Except VW, they’re the best at what they do. Smartest, most fun to listen to. They win.)
More to come? Maybe. Glad we are keeping this blogging up? Yes. I hope all five of you are enjoying it. You know what, I’m not sorry about the length. It’s good to get it out. Thoughts?